Dore
Gold Illustrates UN Goldstone Report Bias Against Israel In
Brandeis Debate
Joel
Leyden
Israel News Agency
Jerusalem
---- November 5, 2009 ..... Israel's defensive war against Hamas
terrorism in Gaza moved tonight to the sleepy and tranquil academic
halls of Brandeis
University.
Former Israel
UN Ambassador Dr. Dore Gold articulated in the most enlightened
manner Israel's right to self-defense against a recognized terror
group - Hamas. Justice Richard Goldstone who was appointed to
lead the UN Human Rights
Council Fact-finding mission on the Israel Gaza Conflict was
left stuttering.
In all fairness,
one could witness that Goldstone is not a stupid individual nor
even anti-Israel. But in the category of being naive as to reality
in the Middle East and the suffering that Israel civilians sustained
by unprovoked Hamas terror rocket attacks over a period of 8 years,
he could easily win an Olympic medal.
Goldstone
complained openly about a nightmare that he had about being kidnapped
by Hamas before entering Gaza as a Jew. But how can Goldstone
compare that one imagined nightmare with the bloody and tearful
reality of one million Israeli civilians suffering under constant
terror rocket attacks for eight years?
"Let
me begin by being very direct. The UN Gaza report is the most
serious and vicious indictment of the State of Israel bearing
the seal of the United Nations since the General Assembly adopted
the 'Zionism is racism' resolution, Gold stated. The
report simply distorts the very essence of what Israel stands
for.
The 575-page
UN report, created by a four-member panel led by the South African
judge Richard Goldstone, details evidence of so called war crimes
committed by Israel.
The debate,
which was the equilvant of the Israel Gaza PR battle, was held
in the shadow of the the United Nations General Assembly voting
in favor of a resolution endorsing a UN sponsored report into
war crimes committed during Israel's war on Gaza.
The Goldstone
report was endorsed by the UN assembly on this evening by a margin
of 114 to 18, after two days of debate.
On Tuesday
the US House of Representatives dismissed the Goldstone report
as being "irredeemably biased" against Israel.
Goldstone,
who had written in his report: the mission concluded that
actions amounting to war crimes and possibly, in some respects,
crimes against humanity, were committed by the Israel Defense
Force (IDF), throughout the debate at Brandeis would refer
to Hamas as a "group of armed men" or as "militants"
while Gold would correct him in defining who Hamas actually is.
Hamas is an
Islamic terror organization, funded by Iran, given the sole purpose
to destroying Israel and or attempting to wipe Israel off the
map.
In stating
that Hamas fully governs Gaza, Goldstone slipped badly on a banana
peel for which he had referred to Gaza as being occupied in earlier
statements. Goldstone was critical of Israel for having blockaded
Gaza, while Gold reminded the South African judge that Israel
allows humanitarian aid into Gaza on a daily basis while pointing
out to the other border for which Gaza shares with Egypt.
"Why
doesn't Egypt open her border up wider to Gaza, why is the UN
only looking at Israel," said an angry yet determined Gold.
Dore Gold,
who serves as the President of
the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs, used video evidence
to illustrate how Hamas used the civilian population of Gaza as
human shields. Further more, Gold provided audio tapes of the
IDF warning Palestinian civilians to leave and separate themselves
from Hamas locations which were being used to fire at the IDF.
"How
much more could Israel have done in displaying herself as a humanitarian
force, we dropped millions of leaflets, used radio, we even sent
messages to thousands of mobile phones to warn the civilian population
to stay away from Hamas, how can the UN state that Israel intentionally
targeted civilians," said Gold.
What
would you do if your population was facing repeated attacks for
eight years? Gold asked, after showing videos showing the
damage created by Hamas terror rockets. Gold pointed out, with
help from aerial maps, that Hamas positions were embedded within
the Arab civilian population.
Gold further
explained that Israel would not cooperate with the Goldstone UN
Report as it was born directly out of politics, not human rights.
That the UN systematically attacks Israel whenever and where ever
it can.
Former United
Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson, had
already stated this fact saying: "I am afraid the resolution
is not balanced. This is unfortunately a practice by the Council:
adopting resolutions guided not by human rights but by politics.
This is very regrettable."
It should
be noted that Brandeis University performed an excellent job in
providing both speakers, especially Gold the opportunity to speak
without being silenced by protesters. As two protesters started
to heckle Gold, representatives of Brandeis immediately reminded
the audience that both men had the right to freedom of speech.
Gold, reinforced that note by saying the the US had fought wars
for that right and the audience should respect it.
One Palestinian
protester was criticized for making comments and not asking questions.
She then asked why their was no Palestinian representative at
the debate. Gold, without hesitation, asked her who should they
invite - Hamas or the Palestinian Authority?
Dore Gold
was in excellent form. At the start of his address, he needed
to clear his throat and start over, but once he got warmed up,
he spoke with the brilliance of Abba Eban. Gold, who received
much applause after taking Goldstone to task on each and every
detail, made every Jew, every human being who believes in democracy
and justice both in the audience and around the world who watched
the Web 2.0 Webcast feel proud of their democratic heritage.
Gold illustrated
the hypocrisy of the UN as he mentioned the Iran terror weapons
ship that was halted in the Mediterranean on Tuesday, carrying
hundreds of tons of rockets and weapons. Those rockets were
intended to kill Israel civilians, he stated.
When asked
about the extent of damage done to civilian buildings in Gaza,
Gold pointed out that the UN report did not mention that Hamas
had booby-trapped buildings in Gaza, had dug tunnels under the
civilian homes. "This war never would have happened if rockets
had not been fired at Israel," he stated. "Remember,
Israel withdrew from Gaza in 2005, and never wanted to go back
there."
Gold concluded
his address by having a video tape played of former Commander
of British Forces in Afghanistan (ret.) Richard Kemp telling the
UNHRC: "During Operation Cast Lead, the Israeli Defense Forces
did more to safeguard the rights of civilians in a combat zone
than any other army in the history of warfare. Israel did so while
facing an enemy that deliberately positioned its military capability
behind the human shield of the civilian population."
The pressure
must have been enormous on Dore Gold. The Israeli chosen to represent
Israel's basic right to defend herself against over 12,000 unprovoked
Hamas terror rocket attacks from Gaza. And Dore came through with
flying colors. Gold was pure shining gold as the debate was updated
minute by minute through Facebook and Twitter.
Dore made
us all proud this evening of the Israel Defense Forces, of the
Israel justice system and of our cherished and respected age old
Jewish humanitarian values.
Former Israel
Prime Minister Golda Meir must have been smiling from above as
Gold spoke with sharp mental edge and pure Zionistic passion.
One could hear her say to Egypt President Anwar Sadat after the
1973 Yom Kippur War: "we can forgive you for killing our
boys, but we can never forgive you for making our boys kill yours."